A troubling case in Palm Beach County is raising serious concerns about safety and accountability in the luxury yachting industry—a world glamorized by shows like Below Deck, but increasingly marred by reports of misconduct.
In a recent investigation by CBS 12 News, a yacht captain named Jack Magruder pled guilty to felony battery after a woman accused him of choking her during a night they spent together after meeting on a dating app. The incident, recorded in a controlled call with Palm Beach Police, is not Magruder’s first brush with the law. He previously served time in Colorado after pleading guilty to sharing intimate photos of a former partner without consent.
Despite these serious charges, Magruder, like many other captains, was able to continue working in the yachting industry—a space where background checks are reportedly minimal or entirely absent.
A Pattern of Problematic Behavior
According to GOLDLAW Chief Legal Officer Spencer Kuvin, this is not an isolated incident. “The problem is that there is very little vetting for these individuals,” Kuvin told CBS 12. “We’re seeing a pattern of captains with criminal records and histories of violent or predatory behavior being put in charge of luxury vessels—essentially placed in positions of power over guests and crew.”
Unfortunately, Magruder is just one example. Other captains, including Brock Horner and John Paul Koston Bader, have been charged with serious crimes ranging from assault to drug smuggling.
Who Is Liable When Things Go Wrong?
In many cases, the captain is the highest authority on board—and the person crew members are supposed to report issues to. But what happens when the captain is the problem?
When yacht owners and management companies fail to properly vet captains—or ignore red flags—they may be exposing themselves to civil liability. GOLDLAW is currently investigating multiple allegations of misconduct tied to negligent hiring practices in the industry.
“If someone hires a captain with a known history of violence or abuse and they hurt someone, we believe the owner or management company should be held accountable,” Kuvin said. “A financial penalty is often the only thing that drives change in industries that have lacked oversight for too long.”
Seeking Justice for Victims
At GOLDLAW, we believe no one should be subjected to abuse—especially not while working or traveling aboard a luxury vessel. Our firm is currently investigating reports from individuals who say they were harmed by a yacht captain or crew member due to negligent hiring, lack of supervision, or misconduct at sea.
If you or someone you love was assaulted, harassed, or harmed aboard a yacht, you may be entitled to financial compensation. Our legal team is here to listen, investigate, and help you pursue justice.
You are not alone. Contact GOLDLAW today at 561-222-2222 or visit GOLDLAW.com to schedule a confidential consultation.
